[2024.06.17 Deutschlandfunk Kultur] Book review "Victimhood natio…
페이지 정보

본문
In this short radio programme on Deutschlandfunk Kultur, the host (not identified by his name) and journalist Jens Balzer discuss Lim's recently published book on national victimhood from a postcolonial perspective. In six minutes, the two tried to discuss the concept of victimhood as a dominant memory feature that can and is intended to strengthen national identity. They do not focus only on the book itself but link it to the current political context, interpreted from a German perspective. Not surprisingly, victimhood nationalism is directly linked to the German memory of Nazi Germany. Describing the German people as victims of the rule of the Nazis and to put central the idea that former features of any heroic memory have been overcome and Germany has learned its lesson (the German word Geschichtsbewältigung is difficult to translate but it means a fundamental break with former topics, features, and narrative figures of memory). As a result, Germans have integrated the motive of guilt for the Holocaust and a particular identification with the fate of Jews and of Israel. This has been has recently come under critique due to the actions of the Israeli army in Gaza. In more general terms we see now coming to the fore what was anticipated in an article by Charles Maier in 2000 when he prognose that the motive of postcoloniality would replace the Holocaust as a central topic in global remembrance processes.
In this context, Lim's work is presented as a highly valuable contribution to the intellectual field of remembrance studies being crucial for the self-understanding of societies. Balzer points out the "unusual perspective" (for both him and the moderator), since it is mostly centred on the "Global East". This perspective, central to Lim’s contribution and related to his origin (South Korea) and his research activities (especially on Poland) remains somehow exotic to Balzer’s view. He therefore escapes into more general considerations. Lim's thesis, according to Balzer, is that memory plays a crucial role in the creation of a collective national identity. Since World War II memory seems to have shifted from a heroic narrative to a narrative that focuses on the victimisation of a nation in order to promote moral purification and collective identity. After briefly summarising the main examples, namely Japan, South Korea, Poland, Germany and Israel, Balzer concludes that competing nationalisms of victimhood are used to obscure self-inflicted crimes in other contexts. Balzer points on the one hand to the danger that victim nationalism can reveal itself, for example, when the Holocaust is used as a comparison for one's own national narrative of victimhood, thereby relativising the Holocaust. On the other hand, he concludes, this concept encourages and promotes a more critical study of our histories, which can lead to an "enlightened" national identity. However, following Lim's argument, this is only possible if one's own role as a (possible) perpetrator is included, acknowledging that the line between victim and perpetrator is fluid, coupled with the individual awareness that everyone can become a perpetrator. In this respect, Balzer concludes that Lim contributes also to the German debate by highlighting the ambivalence and ambiguity in the field of memory and remembrance. At the same time, he remarks that we see in current right-wing populist movements like the AfD a comeback of heroic narratives of national history and at least an attempt to break the dominance of the victimhood memory. The other example that is finally discussed is the capacity of Hamas to present its case as another example of victimhood while Israel seems to represent the role of the heroic. The current global state of affairs seems, according to Balzer, confirm the superiority of victim memory over the heroic version.
All in all, in a relatively short six-minute podcast, the host and Balzer introduce a complex argument to the German readership and relate it to current debates - not necessarily doing justice to the book under review, but rather whetting the intellectual appetite for a topic they also find interesting.
Here you can find the full 6 minute podcast (in German):
https://www.deutschlandfunkkultur.de/buchkritik-opfernationalismus-von-jie-hyun-lim-dlf-kultur-baf95cc3-100.html
In this context, Lim's work is presented as a highly valuable contribution to the intellectual field of remembrance studies being crucial for the self-understanding of societies. Balzer points out the "unusual perspective" (for both him and the moderator), since it is mostly centred on the "Global East". This perspective, central to Lim’s contribution and related to his origin (South Korea) and his research activities (especially on Poland) remains somehow exotic to Balzer’s view. He therefore escapes into more general considerations. Lim's thesis, according to Balzer, is that memory plays a crucial role in the creation of a collective national identity. Since World War II memory seems to have shifted from a heroic narrative to a narrative that focuses on the victimisation of a nation in order to promote moral purification and collective identity. After briefly summarising the main examples, namely Japan, South Korea, Poland, Germany and Israel, Balzer concludes that competing nationalisms of victimhood are used to obscure self-inflicted crimes in other contexts. Balzer points on the one hand to the danger that victim nationalism can reveal itself, for example, when the Holocaust is used as a comparison for one's own national narrative of victimhood, thereby relativising the Holocaust. On the other hand, he concludes, this concept encourages and promotes a more critical study of our histories, which can lead to an "enlightened" national identity. However, following Lim's argument, this is only possible if one's own role as a (possible) perpetrator is included, acknowledging that the line between victim and perpetrator is fluid, coupled with the individual awareness that everyone can become a perpetrator. In this respect, Balzer concludes that Lim contributes also to the German debate by highlighting the ambivalence and ambiguity in the field of memory and remembrance. At the same time, he remarks that we see in current right-wing populist movements like the AfD a comeback of heroic narratives of national history and at least an attempt to break the dominance of the victimhood memory. The other example that is finally discussed is the capacity of Hamas to present its case as another example of victimhood while Israel seems to represent the role of the heroic. The current global state of affairs seems, according to Balzer, confirm the superiority of victim memory over the heroic version.
All in all, in a relatively short six-minute podcast, the host and Balzer introduce a complex argument to the German readership and relate it to current debates - not necessarily doing justice to the book under review, but rather whetting the intellectual appetite for a topic they also find interesting.
Here you can find the full 6 minute podcast (in German):
https://www.deutschlandfunkkultur.de/buchkritik-opfernationalismus-von-jie-hyun-lim-dlf-kultur-baf95cc3-100.html
- 이전글[2024.06.19 시사오늘] 민추협, ‘김대중과 6월항쟁’ 기념세미나 연다 24.06.21
- 다음글[2024.06.15 문학뉴스] 20~23일 ‘폭력의 지층들’ 영화제...국내외 10편 상영 24.06.17
댓글목록
등록된 댓글이 없습니다.
![[2024.06.17 Deutschlandfunk Kultur] Book review "Victimhood nationalism“ by Jie-Hyun Lim > 언론보도](/kor/image/logo.gif)
